LOS ANGELES COUNTY
METROPOLITAN TRANSPORTATION AUTHORITY
REGULAR BOARD MEETING
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
Metro Headquarters
3rd Floor - Board Room
One Gateway Plaza
Los Angeles
December 18, 1997
Called to order at: 9:40 a.m.
Directors/Alternates Present:
Jaime de la Vega
Yvonne Brathwaite Burke/Michael Bohlke, First Vice Chair
James Cragin/George Nakano, Second Vice Chair
Richard Alatorre/Nate Holden
Michael Antonovich/Nick Patsaouras
Hal Bernson
John Fasana/Beatrice La Pisto-Kirtley
Don Knabe/Robert Arthur
Jose Legaspi/Jackie Goldberg
Gloria Molina
Jenny Oropeza
Zev Yaroslavsky/Robert Abernethy
Larry Zarian/Jan Heidt
Tony V. Harris
Interim Chief Executive Officer - Julian Burke
Board Secretary - Georgia Hamilton
Inspector General - Arthur Sinai
General Counsel - County Counsel
1. Consider approval of Consent Calendar Items 15 through 23 Consent Calendar Addendum Items A through G
(Consent Calendar Addendum - Items Approved Under Committee Authority)
APPROVED: Items 15 through 20, 22 and 23 of the consent calendar, Item #21 pulled for discussion; and items A-G of the Consent Calendar Addendum. |
Directors voting - Bernson, Burke, Nakano, Knabe, Fasana, Oropeza, Yaroslavsky, Zarian, de la Vega (Conflicts: Item #17) - Knabe, Fasana, Yaroslavsky
2. Consider approval of minutes of Special Board Meeting held November 13, 1997.
APPROVED |
3. Chief Executive Officers ReportThanked the employees for their support and extended holiday greetings. Adopted resolution for Rae James, departing Executive Officer, Customer Services & Communication.
NON-CONSENT ITEMS
4. BERNSON - Consider approving staff to work with the Department of Transportation (DOT), to determine which Smart Shuttle routes can be restructured to accommodate ridership on major bus corridors in whichweekendservice has been proposed for cancellation by the Metro and report back in 30 days.
APPROVED AS AMENDED: Use of mobility allowance to contract with LADOT or other entities to immediately replace cancelled service. |
Directors Voting: Bernson, Burke, Cragin, Knabe, Fasana, Oropeza, Yaroslavsky, Zarian, de la Vega, Knabe, Fasana, Antonovich, Molina
5. BERNSON - Receive report on funding designated by the State legislation for transit in the San Fernando Valley and commence an investigation on the whereabouts of the Valley Trust Fund.
APPROVED AS AMENDED, to direct staff to prepare and present to the Inspector General within 30 days for his examination and to the Board within 60 days a detailed report as to how funds designated as "The Valley Trust Fund" were computed, how and where they were deposited, a determination of the total of the funds accrued, including account numbers, remaining balance, if any, and identification of the accounts where the accrued interest may have been deposited. |
Directors Voting: Bernson, Burke, Cragin, Knabe, Fasana, Oropeza, Yaroslavsky, Zarian, de la Vega, Knabe, Fasana, Antonovich, Molina
6. ALATORRE - Consider direction to the CEO to prepare a studyprior to the Boards final consideration of the capital budgeton the feasibility of establishing a funding allocation policy to include:
A. commencing with the adoption of the FY 1999 budget, establish a policy to allocate at least 40% of Proposition C Discretionary funds to fund capital projects, including payments of principal and interest on existing bonds for capital programs;
B. a determination of the amount of future bonding capacity for capital programs that will be achieved by the adoption of the aforementioned funding allocation formula;
C. commencing with the adoption of the FY 1999 budget, the establishment of a policy to allocate all Proposition A Rail Development funds to fund rail capital projects, including payments of principal and interest on existing bonds rail construction bonds; and
D. an assessment of the impact on other Metro programs resulting from the adoption of all these funding allocation formulas.
E. Assessment to be made on the alternative uses of such funds for Countywide operations and services;
APPROVED AS AMENDED to add item E - Staff to report back at the regular Board Meeting in January, 1998. |
Directors Voting: Bernson, Burke, Cragin, Knabe, Fasana, Oropeza, Yaroslavsky, Zarian, de la Vega, Knabe, Fasana, Antonovich, Molina
7. ALARCON - Consider approval for staff to begin discussion with LADOT and other transit agencies as well as the cities of San Fernando, Calabasas, Burbank, Glendale, Agoura Hills, Santa Clarita and the County Dept. of Public Works to further evaluate the benefits of a transit zone in the San Fernando Valley and to determine: a) Metros allocated costs for transit services in the San Fernando Valley, and b) the method used to determine the allocation of funds in the San Fernando Valley.APPROVED AS AMENDED |
Directors Voting: Bernson, Burke, Cragin, Knabe, Fasana, Oropeza, Yaroslavsky, Zarian, de la Vega, Knabe, Fasana, Antonovich, Molina
8. YAROSLAVSKY/ANTONOVICH - Response to Board request. Receive and file report on San Fernando Valley service options.
RECEIVED AND FILED (Staff to report back monthly) |
9. Consider authorizing the CEO to: (PP 4) A. Enter into an Exclusive Negotiation Agreement between TrizecHahn Centers Management, Inc. and the LACMetro for a 180-day extension covering the development of properties adjacent to Hollywood/ Highland Metro Red Line Station;
B. Sign applications for development entitlements on the Metro-owned property at the Hollywood/Highland Station.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: APPROVED AS AMENDED; DESIGN IS SUBJECT TO APPROVAL OF Metro AND COUNCIL (DISTRICT 13-CITY OF LA)
APPROVED COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION |
Directors Voting: Bernson, Burke, Cragin, Knabe, Fasana, Oropeza, Zarian, de la Vega, Knabe, Fasana, Antonovich, Molina Conflict, Yaroslavsky
10. Consider award of contracts covering services in (EMC association with federal legislative advocacy support for a 3) total cost of $332,314 the year ending December 31, 1998:
MARC Asso. & Cliff Madison Govt. Rels. $100,402 American Continental Group 90,152 The Jefferson Group 72,650 Palumbo & Cerrell, Inc. 69,110
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: CEO is authorized to extend current contracts up to 60 days and requested to make an evaluation of the best people for our legislative representation based upon the legislative plan and to work with the Executive Management Committee to submit a final recommendation to the Board through Executive Management Committee.
APPROVED COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION |
Directors Voting: Bernson, Burke, Cragin, Knabe, Fasana, Oropeza, Yaroslavsky, Zarian, de la Vega, Knabe, Fasana, Antonovich, Molina
11. Consider award of contracts covering services in (EMC association with state legislative advocacy support for a 4) total cost of $193,500 the year ending December 31, 1998:
Capital Representation Group $70,300 Nielsen, Merksamer, Parrinello & Naylor 57,130 JEA & Associates 40,850 Nossaman, Guthner, Knox & Elliot 25,250
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: CEO is authorized to extend current contracts up to 60 days and requested to make an evaluation of the best people for our legislative representation based upon the legislative plan and to work with the Executive Management Committee to submit a final recommendation to the Board through Executive Management Committee.
APPROVED COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION |
Directors Voting: Bernson, Burke, Cragin, Knabe, Fasana, Oropeza, Zarian, Knabe, Fasana, Antonovich, Molina ; 2 Conflict (Yaroslavsky, Riordan)
12. Consider an increase to the Authorization for Expenditure to Contracts EN032, International Technology Corporation, EN030, CH2MHILL and EN031, Metcalf & Eddy, Inc., the current panel of environmental waste services, covering removal and disposal of hazardous substance contamination on the East Side Extension in the amount of$2,360,000$300,000 for a total AFE in the amount of$4,205,000. $2,145,000
APPROVED AS CORRECTED |
Directors Voting: Bernson, Cragin, Knabe, Fasana, Oropeza, Yaroslavsky, Zarian, Knabe, Fasana, Antonovich, Molina; 1 Absent (Burke); 1 Conflict (Riordan)
13. Consider approval of:
A. Change Order No. 93 to Contract C0311 with Traylor Bros./Frontier-Kemper, JV, in the amount of $619,175 which includes costs for future work deferred by the Board and covers a portion of the settlement of Claim No. 6 as recommended by the Dispute Review Board; and
B. an increase to the Authorization for Expenditure in the amount of $619,175 for a revised AFE in the amount of $167,158,974.
APPROVED |
Directors Voting: Bernson, Cragin, Knabe, Fasana, Oropeza, Yaroslavsky, Zarian, de la Vega, Knabe, Fasana, Antonovich, Molina
14. Consider approving the sale of property located at 5557 St. Elmo Walk, Long Beach for approximately $248,000 net proceeds as settlement in full of the mortgage loan.
APPROVED |
Directors Voting: Bernson, Burke, Cragin, Knabe, Fasana, Oropeza, Zarian, de la Vega, Knabe, Fasana, Antonovich; 1 No Yaroslavsky
CONSENT CALENDAR ITEMS
15. Consider: (FB 1) A. adoption of the revised Metro Investment Policy; and
B. delegation of authority to invest Metro funds to the Metro Treasurer, for a one year period, pursuant to California Government Code Section 53607.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: APPROVE
APPROVED ON CONSENT CALENDAR |
16. Consider approval of an increase in the contract spending (FB 2) limit for the Audit Pool Contract RFP No. PS2510-0071 in force until December 1, 1998, in an amount not to exceed $500,000 for the outsourcing of Financial, Performance and Third Party Contract audits.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: APPROVE
APPROVED ON CONSENT CALENDAR |
17. Authorize the execution of a ten-year license agreement (FB 3) with Southern California Edison Company (SCE) and approval of rental payments in the amount of $358,455 over the ten- year term for the continuing usage of the Marine Station parking facility for the Metro Green Line (D Line) Project.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: APPROVE
APPROVED ON CONSENT CALENDAR |
18. Consider amending the Measures and Public Hearing (PP 1) Procedures for Major Service or Fare Changes.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: APPROVE
APPROVED ON CONSENT CALENDAR |
19. Consider: (PP 3) A. appointing the TDA Article 8 Hearing Board to conduct unmet transit needs hearings in those eligible areas outside the Metro service area;
B. appointing members to a three-year term to fill vacant positions on the FY 1998-99 Social Service Transportation Advisory Council (SSTAC) and extend the term by one year, through FY 1999-2000, for returning members; and
C. authorizing the CEO, or his designee, to annually appoint the TDA Article 8 Hearing Board and to fill vacancies on the SSTAC.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: APPROVE
APPROVED ON CONSENT CALENDAR |
20. Consider addition of Directors Special Items to future (EMC Board Meeting Agendas. 2)
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: APPROVE, encourage use of 72 hour notice.
APPROVED ON CONSENT CALENDAR |
21. Consider: (CC 5) A. Revision No. 1 to Contract Work Order No. 47 to Contract E0070 with Engineering Management Consultant covering final design services on the East Side Extension project adding a testing program for precast concrete tunnel liner and gaskets in the negotiated/audited amount of $327,507 extending the period of performance to June 30, 1998;
B. an increase to the Authorization for Expenditure in the amount of $328,000 increasing the AFE to $5,408,000.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: APPROVE
MOTION
to approve staff recommendation - FAILED MOTION to carry over to January - FAILED NO ACTION TAKEN |
FAILED BY THE FOLLOWING ROLL CALL VOTE:
Ayes: Bernson, Bohlke, Cragin, Lapisto-Kirtley, de la Vega
Noes: Legaspi, Oropeza, Heidt
Abstain: Patsouras
Absent: Alatorre, Molina
22. Consider approval of a contract amendment with Neoplan USA (OPS Corporation covering various changes to the contract for 250 6) buses detailed in Contract Amendment No. 1, for a net decrease of $2,309,718.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: APPROVE
APPROVED ON CONSENT CALENDAR |
23. Consider approval of request from the Los Angeles County (OPS Sheriffs Department to transfer one surplus bus (#8698) for 7) the purpose of training personnel.
COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATION: APPROVE
APPROVED ON CONSENT CALENDAR |
CLOSED SESSION
24. Conference with real property negotiators concerning price and/or terms of sale - G.C. 54956.8:
Parcel AS-348 Rosecrans Overpass Project Owners - Yon Kyu Kim and Ki Sook Kim
APPROVED LITIGATION SETTLEMENT $585, 000 |
25. Conference with Legal Counsel - Existing Litigation - G.C. 54956.9
A. Nestlerode v. Metro Superior Court Case No. Y4C018577
APPROVED SETTLEMENT OF $25,000 |
B. Lin v. Metro Superior Court Case No. BC 155802
APPROVED SETTLEMENT IN THE AMOUNT OF $250,000 |
C. Lowry v. Metro Superior Court Case No. BC 162555
APPROVED SETTLEMENT OF $400,000 |
26. Conference with Legal Counsel - Existing Litigation - G.C. 54956.9 (a)
Wiltern Associates v. Metro LASC Case No. BC113523
NO REPORT |
RECEIVED PUBLIC COMMENTDirector Oropeza requested a report on the cost of providing Metro Bus information 7 days a week.
Meeting was adjourned at 1:30 p.m.
CONSENT CALENDAR ADDENDUM COMMITTEE APPROVALS
THE FOLLOWING ITEMS WERE APPROVED UNDER COMMITTEE AUTHORITY.
Construction Committee
A. Consider approval of Change Order No. 95 to Contract No. C0311 with Traylor Bros./Frontier-Kemper, JV, for credit amount of $310,000 for relocation of the track level rooms and crosspassage #49 for tunnel line section to Universal City reducing the contract amount to $154,265,400 and the AFE to $166,229,799.
APPROVED UNDER COMMITTEE AUTHORITY, 4/5 VOTE
B. Consider approval of Change Order No. 21 to Contract No. B641 with Amelco Electronics, Inc., covering design, procurement, installation and testing of on-frequency repeaters at the Segment 2 stations and the Central Control Facility in the amount of $237,383.
APPROVED UNDER COMMITTEE AUTHORITY, 4/5 VOTE
C. Consider approval of cancellation and re- solicitation of Invitation for Bid No. C0361 covering the Maintenance of Way Facility as a design/build project for the Metro Green Line (D Line).
APPROVED UNDER COMMITTEE AUTHORITY, 4/5 VOTE
Operations Committee
D. Consider award of a three-year contract to City Terrace Services, Los Angeles, covering Metro Freeway Service Patrol towing for Beat 25 commencing March 31, 1998 in the amount of $1,117,500.
COMMITTEE AUTHORITY, 4/5 VOTE
E. Consider the following actions covering modifications to existing buildings at the Regional Rebuild Center:
A. rescind previous action by the Board to reject all bids; and
B. award a contract to Mallcraft, Inc., Pasadena, the lowest responsive, responsible bidder, covering modifications to existing buildings at the Regional Rebuild Center for a fixed price of $1,627,000.
COMMITTEE AUTHORITY, 4/5 VOTE
F. Consider award of contracts to the lowest responsive, responsible bidders covering a 12 month supply of hand products for a total bid price of $415,211:
A. Unisource $ 20,853 Items 1, 6 & 7 B. Gale Supply Co. 349,802 Items 2, 3 & 5 C. Clean Source 31,724 Item 4 D. Easterday Janitorial Supply 12,832 Items 8 & 9
COMMITTEE AUTHORITY, 4/5 VOTE
G. Consider award of contract to Westinghouse Air Brake Co., the lowest responsive, responsible bidder covering overhaul of 108 couplers for the Metro Blue Line Light Rail vehicles for a fixed price of $388,726, and an option to overhaul an additional 30 couplers for the Metro Green Line (D Line) Light Rail vehicles for a fixed price of $107,979.
COMMITTEE AUTHORITY, 4/5 VOTE